Friday, 15 May 2009

  • Protein Bars: What Are Some Reasonably Priced and Nutritious Bars I Can Buy?


    I'm looking for better ways to consume protein. I eat a lot of seafood, chicken, and turkey and that just doesn't seem to cut anymore. I need something more. I used to eat protein bars, but I don't want to spend an arm and a leg on them. I've seen those mega ones and they just seem way too much for me.

    Sure, it has like 30 grams of protein and 46 grams of carbs, but I don't think that they're for me.

    Is there a way to figure out which ones are the right bars to get? What are some reasonably priced and tasty protein bars that you would recommend?


Comments (19)

  • perfectis33x23x33@xanga

    I would 100% recommend Promax bars from Trader Joe's.. Cookies and cream is my favorite! They taste great and have a good amount of protein too.

  • LadyLibellule@xanga

    If you already eat a lot of seafood, chicken, and turkey, you're probably getting more than enough protein already.

    There is such a thing as too much protein; don't abuse your poor kidneys.

  • Vwarriormodel25@xanga

    I like the peanut butter protein bars from the South Beach Diet people. It has 10g of protein per serving and they taste great if you like peanut butter (:

  • Shake_down_1979@xanga

    anything from trader joe's is good and cheaper than anywhere else. I would recommend using protein powders and putting it in stuff like cereal and yogurt instead.It's a cheaper option. Also, of them all, I recommend 100% egg protein powder over whey or soy.Also, Egg protein is the most absorbable type of protein by the body.

  • Shock_Every0ne@xanga

    I think you could make your own tasty bars
    with oats,protein powder,bananas, and nuts yum

  • Yipz

    MAKE YOUR OWN!!!!!!


    good eats part 1
    good eats part 2
    gogogogoGOGOOGOGOGOgogoogoggo
  • Peachass@xanga

    i've always been told life brand is the best (from shopper's drug mart or wal-mart)
    don't know if Life Brand is availible in ur area, though

  • MrsOrganic

    there are none reasonably priced that i would recommend.


    if you are concerned about protein, it sounds to me like you may be
    misinformed about how much you need (most Americans are). If you are
    eating a decent amount of protein rich foods plus a balanced diet of
    fruits and veggies, there is absolutely no need for additional protein.


    a draw back about these bars is they are loaded with sugar, and they
    are HIGHLY processed and therefore require a LOT of preservatives. So
    you are ingesting a lot of dead food that has been pumped full of
    synthetic vitamins and chemicals to compensate for lack of nutrition
    and and taste.


    another thing to look out for is what source of protein is in those
    bars. many people believe soy is a good option, and nothing could be
    further from the truth. also the whey protein and milk solids found in
    many of these is actually processed in such a way that it is loaded
    with MSG, another very harmful chemical.


    The only bars I recommend and buy myself are Prana Bars. They have no
    soy or dairy, HFCS, are minimally processed. Where I shop they are $2
    each. These are not necessarily meal replacement but could be, and
    provide a few extra grams of protein and naturally occurring vitamins.

    Like Yipz said, you should look into making your own. This is almost always a better option, and it will be fresher and probably cheaper, and you will know exactly what is in it.

  • MrsOrganic

    @Yipz - the first video was awesome but i disagreed with almost everything in the second one. lol oh well.

  • imyourstargirl@xanga

    I think your diet gives you plenty of protein... but if it doesn't cut it, then you might want to go to a specialty food store like Trader Joe's or Whole Foods.

  • hexogen@xanga

    Protein is overrated these days.

  • SeiGe_Jet@xanga

    @MrsOrganic - You pretty much hit the nail right on the head.


    There is no substitute for quality protein found in beef, poultry, seafood, etc. Protein bars are nothing more than glorified snickers... call a spade a spade. If possible, you should never, ever substitute a balanced meal with a bar ---- and definitely wouldn't try using as a meal replacement no matter how appealing that may sound. It's questionable as a supplement. So stick to your seafood, chicken and turkey... if you need your protein for a specific purpose, you can figure out which whey isolate (not concentrate) or casein protein to consume in order to get the results you want. Consult with a nutritionist/dietician for additional questions, since all our bodies may not react the same way when introduced to a new diet/supplement/etc.

  • Brunhilda@xanga

    I eat Zone bars for a breakfast on the run, then fruit as a snack later.  You only need about 1 gm/kg of your weight in protein.  If you weigh 120 lbs that's 50-60 gm of protein a day. Don't check that math too closely.  I don't eat a lot of meat, so the Zone bars aren't bad.  About $1.59 a bar, but I buy the boxes at Sam's or Costco.  

  • Blue_ButterflyBaby@xanga

    I would love to get some protein bars or protein shakes or something myself.  I am ready to up my protein intake as well.

  • gnostic2

    Many studies have shown that consuming extra protein does none of the things that the consumer is looking for. In many studies muscle gain is actually better in participants consuming everyday food with an average protein amount.

  • anonymous

    I am amazed. The original poster asked specifically about choosing protein bars, but more than half the respondents offered their opinion on whether she was getting too much protein.

    One of my regular Avon customers just had gastric bypass surgery a few months ago and she was telling me the guidelines that the nutritionist had set for her, one of which was a greater amount of protein that the "normal" person should have.  Low sugar protein bars were on the printout of suggested food items for bypass patients after surgery.

    I'm not saying that the person who posted the question falls into the above category.  What I'm saying is that there may be a valid reason why she needs the extra protein so perhaps responses should stay within the scope of the original question.

  • skinnychic8@xanga

    I like to make Tightcurves protein brownies instead of buying a lot of protein bars with tons of filler in them, however I do buy protein bars occasionally. I like the Balance & SlimFast bars when I can afford them, but for  the most part I make protein brownies, the recipe is on the TightCurves website.

  • skinnychic8@xanga

    @Brunhilda@xanga - Zone bars aren't bad :] I forgot about those!

  • eskeemo_kisses@xanga

    @TL - I forgot all about this post. I haven't had any surgeries, but I know for a fact that if I add more protein to my daily diet, it helps with the fat loss. I've done it before, but I don't do exactly the same thing I did before and they're not the same bars. I'm trying to get back on track.

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About the Author

Who recommended?