Monday, 06 July 2009
-
How Do I Know What a Healthy Weight is For Me?
What exactly is a healthy weight? Due to increased media influence and other factors, it can be difficult to judge what your body should look like. We see models everywhere that appear thin and fit. Are their weights what we should be aiming for? In reality, many models are not at a medically healthy weight - instead they are underweight, and being underweight can cause just as many medical problems as being overweight. If we shouldn't be looking to fashion models for health, then where should we look? It's back to the textbooks and research for this one as we explore some different methods of determining what a healthy weight really is.
Weight to Height Ratios
Body Mass Index
When determining a healthy weight, one can use a variety of methods - the most popular being Body Mass Index (BMI). Your BMI is calculated from your weight and your height. It does not directly determine your percentage of body fat, but through research it has been determined that it is reliable for most individuals. If you are a serious athlete, it may not be as accurate due to increased percentage of muscle mass.
BMI
category
<18.5
underweight
18.5-25
healthy
25-30
overweight
30-35
obese
35-40
significantly obese
40-45
morbidly obese
45-50
super obese
>50
super-morbidly obese
The metric system calculation is simple:
weight(kg) / height(m)2
or you can use this modified formula for the English system:
( weight(lb) / height(in)2 ) * 703
For instance, if someone was 5'5" (65 in, 1.65 m) and 130 lbs (59 kg) they would have a BMI of 21.67, thus putting them in the healthy weight range for their height.
You can also use this handy chart:
An interesting website allows you to see what people would describe as their ideal weight based on your height along with your BMI and several other formulas.
Body Fat PercentageAnother category of determining healthy weight is through body fat percentage. This allows you to determine what amount of weight on your body is due to fat-free mass (vital organs, muscle, skin, etc.) and what amount of weight is due to fat. There are several ways to do this including the use of a body fat formula, calipers, bioelectrical impedance, and hydrostatic weighing.
women
men
essential fat
10-12%
2-4%
lean/athletes
14-20%
6-13%
ideal
21-24%
14-17%
average
25-31%
18-25%
overfat
32%+
25%+
Calculating your ideal weight from your percent body fat
Again, take a look at the 5'5" (165 cm), 130 lb (59 kg) person. Let's say that she has used one of the following methods to calculate her percent body fat and has found it to be 30%. The highest ideal body fat percentage she should have is 24%, so she needs to lose 6% of her body fat. Multiply her current weight, 130 lbs, by .06 to find the amount of fat she should lose. 130 * .06 = 7.8 lbs. Subtract this from her current weight to find her ideal weight: 130 - 7.8 = 122.2 lbs. Ideally, she should weigh 122.2 lbs (55.4 kg).
Body Fat Formula
There are actually several formulas that can be used to estimate percentage body fat.
Formula 1:Body Fat % = (1.20 x BMI) + (0.23 x Age) - (10.8 x gender) - 5.4
(male gender= 1, female=0)
Body Fat Formula For Women
Factor 1
(Total body weight x 0.732) + 8.987
Factor 2
Wrist measurement (at fullest point) / 3.140
Factor 3
Waist measurement (at naval) x 0.157
Factor 4
Hip measurement (at fullest point) x 0.249
Factor 5
Forearm measurement (at fullest point) x 0.434
Lean Body Mass
Factor 1 + Factor 2 - Factor 3 - Factor 4 + Factor 5
Body Fat Weight
Total bodyweight - Lean Body Mass
Body Fat Percentage
(Body Fat Weight x 100) / total bodyweight
Body Fat Formula For Men
Factor 1
(Total body weight x 1.082) + 94.42
Factor 2
Waist measurement x 4.15
Lean Body Mass
Factor 1 - Factor 2
Body Fat Weight
Total bodyweight - Lean Body Mass
Body Fat Percentage
(Body Fat Weight x 100) / total bodyweight
Or you can use this handy calculator.
Skin-fold Measurement
Another way to measure body fat percentage is through the use of calipers. Calipers are tools that measure skin-folds on certain areas of the body. The theory behind calipers is that half of a person's fat lies just below the skin. It is best to have this done by a professional, as it is difficult to get accurate measurements unless you are experienced. However, you can do this at home. Calipers can be purchased off of many different fitness websites or at your local sporting goods store.
Hydrostatic Weighing
Hydrostatic weighing is more commonly known by lay persons as underwater weighing because, well, you're literally weighed underwater. This method of measuring body fat is considered to be the most accurate; it is also the most difficult to do at home. However, if you can find a facility near you that is set up for it (such as a some fitness gyms, universities, or research facilities), it's quite easy to do. First your dry weight is determined, then you are weighed under water. These weights are used to calculate your body density, which can then be used to calculate your percent body fat using the Siri equation.
Body Density = Wa / (((Wa - Ww) / Dw) - (RV + 100cc))
Wa = weight (kg) in air
Ww = weight (kg) in water
Dw = density of water
RV = residual volume of air in lungsBioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA)
You know those silver plates that you see on certain bathroom scales? Well, they measure your percent body fat based on bioelectrical impedance. BIA is based on the idea that fat-free tissues, where the majority of body water is located, are better conductors of electricity than fat. To do this, a small electrical current is sent through the body and the resistance is measured. The amount of electrical resistance is then correlated with the amount of fat-free tissue and, taking into consideration your weight and height, this is used to calculate your percent body fat.
Body Frame, Weight, and Height
Another method to determine a healthy weight (which is considered more accurate than BMI yet less accurate than body fat percentage) is by comparing your weight, height, and body frame. Although no person is exactly alike in body structure, body frames are measured in three different sizes: small, medium, and large.
The easiest way to figure out what type of frame you have is by wrapping your thumb and pointer finger around your opposite wrist between the bony part and your hand. If your fingers overlap you have a small frame. If they barely touch you have a medium frame. If they don't touch you have a large frame. For a more accurate way to determine your body frame size, you can go to this website.
To figure out your ideal weight based on your height and frame size, you can use an online calculator (click here or here).
So that's about it!
Have you used any method to determine how much you should ideally weigh? Are you at a healthy weight for your height?
Post a Comment
- Back to healthkicker's Healthkicker Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in healthkicker's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)




















Comments (37)
I'm 5'6" and 133 lbs.. I think I'm at a healthy weight... Ive seen bigger people than me at this height. My BMI is 20.. so I guess its healthy.
it's too complicated someone do the math for me please.... ,lol
im 5'2'' and 101 lbs right now.
i was 108 lbs a month ago >.>
i would just like to make a quick comment, a healthy BMI for -women- is lower than 18.5. i think it's 17.
and i think people should know if their healthy or not just by how they feel, what they eat, and how often they exercise. i've always wanted to know my percentage of body fat, though!
i have a BMI of 17.3 or so. 5'8, 115-117lbs
Well, I just did. My BMI is 23 and I need to lose five pounds.
Damn. I'm fat.
@aiinos@xanga - Yes, you're at a healthy weight. Don't worry about it!
@marshmellowTM@xanga - Your current BMI is 18.5, just at the borderline to being underweight. Your previous BMI (at 108 lbs) was 19.8.
@PenaltyLife@xanga - All the sites I've looked at have said that a healthy BMI for women is 18.5 to 25. If you find a site that says differently, could you maybe send me the link?
People most definitely should judge whether or not they're healthy by more than just their BMI.
@heartsncrossbones@xanga - Your BMI is 23! You're in the normal range, try not to fret about it. :)
So the first body fat formula yields 6% higher for me than the second... interesting.
@nevermore_x13@xanga - Body fat formulas are notoriously inaccurate. I'd suggest trying one of the other methods to determine your body fat. I'd go with formula 2 honestly, it seems to make more sense.
@just__one__me@xanga - this site used to say it outright but i guess they edited it to not but a definite number: http://www.halls.md/body-mass-index/bmi.htm i plugged in different weights, a bmi of 17.5 is "healthy." also, i know this probably doesn't even count, but my weight has gone down even to 113, and my wii fit still says i'm in the healthy range. the wii fit definitely set the healthy bmi extreme at 17.
i think saying 18.5 is the bottom tier of healthy weight is ridiculous. i haven't had a bmi that high in two years, and i'm in great shape. when my bmi was above 18.5, i was a little chubby (still thinner than the average person my age) and lived a very sedentary life style.
and reading over my last comment, my bmi was off. i'm actually 17.5 or 17.6.
5'8" and 148 lbs. a healthy weight, but i'm trying to lose some lbs cuz a size 6 would suit my medium frame better than the 8 i am now.
@PenaltyLife@xanga - I guess it just depends on your frame size as to what a low healthy BMI is. I have a friend who is 5'6" and 97 lbs, but she is quite healthy.
@choosingausernameishard@xanga - I too am trying to lose weight even though I'm in the "healthy" range. I'm 5'5" and I'd like to get down to 116 lbs from the 130 I am now.
My BMI is 18.9 but previously it was 19.1.. And I lost 6 lbs... but the shocking thing was when my BMI was 19.1, my fat percentage was 24%.
Currently, it is 22%. So I don't really care what the BMI says for me, it's about fat %. I used to be obsessed with that and the number the scale would read, but not anymore.. :)
Wayyy too much effort for me. I'll just ask my doctor. (Y) I know my BMI is healthy though.
Idk. BMI doesn't tell me much because I have a very wide and heavy bone structure.
19.6... fat :(
I usually go by BMI. I'm at 22 for me, but according to my body fat percentage I need to be around 130 to be at 24%. Currently, again according to the calculation, I'm around 26% body fat and I weigh 134...looks like my weight loss goals are realistic and healthy in both of those areas.
I realize neither option is considered completely accurate, but I suppose it's something to go off of aside from numbers on the scale and measuring yourself.
i calculated it myself before, but i don't remember... my doctor said it's fine though.
@PenaltyLife@xanga - i'd like to add to that and say that i think the healthy weight for women should be from 17.5-20, maximum 21. i've gone the whole spectrum, from 16.5 to 25.5, and when i had a bmi of anything that was above 21, i was, putting it plainly, fat. my fingers were chubby and i had puffy cheeks. i've not gotten this from any website, this is just from personal experience.
@just__one__me@xanga - thank you! i figured how u read that chart lol but last night i wasnt in to the mood.
5'6" and 138ish and I'm perfectly fine. lol 22.1!
I need to lose 20lbs for me to be in the middle of the healthy zone. But I want to lose 35lbs to get back into the weight of my college years LOL.
My BMI is 25.47 and I definitely still have a little fat I could shave off, but I don't think I actually have enough fat left on my body to get to BMI 22 (which would require losing over 20 more pounds) and still be healthy, unless some of that was shedding muscle mass. I did the body frame test, but it suggests that I have a small body frame.
That said, I'm not an athelete or anything, although I do work out frequently, so I'm thinking I just don't fit the regular body type for BMI to be accurate. Might have to see if I can get a body fat percentage test done, so I can set a better measurable goal.
@Mercredi@lovelyish - 19.6 is NOT fat! I'd love to have your BMI.
@musiciansbox@xanga - I disagree. I think the healthy range of BMI is good where it's at. My BMI is currently 21.5 and I've never been told that I'm fat. I think that maybe the low end should be lowered somewhat because there are people who have very small body frames.
@johnjihoonchang@xanga - Getting a body fat percentage test done definitely sounds like it would make more sense for you than just relying on BMI alone.
where's super :duper" obese
according to the charts and formulas i am obese. i'm 5'5" but if i weighed 120 i would look anorexic! i know i am overwieght but i sure dont LOOK obese. i got a nice voluptuous figure and for the most part i'm happy about he way i look. i wouldnt mind losing about 25 pounds but if it means i'm gonna lose my curves i aint that enthused about it.
i think it's all about being comfy in your skin and staying healthy. all my blood tests and junk are fine. i eat a fairly balanced diet and exercise whenever i can (which is admittedly hard to find the time to do when u wrk and go to school full time!) and i get compliments all the time, so i'm not overly concerned. just gotta stay balanced and be happy with yourself!
I'm at 23. It feels fat, I want to lose weight.