Thursday, 15 March 2012
-
Is Addiction a Choice?
Unless you've lived under a rock for the past seven years, you know what the TV show Intervention is. Basically, an unsuspecting addict is tricked into thinking they're cool enough to get a documentary made about them. In actuality, it's a bunch of A&E producers and the addicts' friends and family staging an intervention. In case you haven't seen Intervention and you don't know what an intervention is, it's just a giant ultimatum; get clean or GTFO.
In the show, we see addicts from all walks of life abusing drugs and alcohol, abandoning their kids, stealing from loved ones, and breaking the law, among other things. many other things. You will hear countless family members talk about all the wretched things that have happened to them thanks to their addict family members, and numerous times I've heard "The drug has a hold of him/her. He/she can't help he's/she's addicted."
This belief pisses me off to no end. I would like to clear up right away that I am a smoker, and have used plenty of drugs in my life, so I think I have a pretty clear view from this angle. Not to mention the fact that I may know more people with drug problems than without. Moving on.
Addiction sucks, it really does. Anyone who has ever been addicted or has known an addict firsthand, know this. It takes your brain and won't let you think of anything but your vice until you can't do anything but curl up in fetal position and weep. And this isn't mentioning the withdrawals that come with extreme cases of dependency. Headaches, nausea, vomiting, dizziness, cold sweats, tremors, diarrhea, muscle pains, and hallucinations are just the tip of the iceberg. So, yes, addiction does suck. It is, however, entirely up to the user when he or she uses. Addiction doesn't mug an innocent elderly, take you to the dealer, lift your arm and get you high. Although it may make it loads easier, it was you who made the choices. I'm sick of people getting away with murder, literally murder, because they were under the influence and therefore "not criminally responsible." Drugs and alcohol are a choice you make, and anything resulting in behavior affected by said drugs or alcohol should be your responsibility. These days it is no secret, even to young users, that drugs come with the possibility of addiction.
Even people who smoke cigarettes say things along the lines of "I can't help it, it's not my choice I'm a smoker." Uh, yeah, it is.
What do you think, is addiction a choice?
Post a Comment
- Back to healthkicker's Healthkicker Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in healthkicker's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)



Recommend


Comments (66)
Ehh... I don't like how you worded it.
Yeah, it's their choice to START, but whether or not they can stop, isn't entirely up to them since the addiction does have a hold of the addict. They can't help it, meaning, they cannot stop. Maybe you misunderstood what they meant.
There's free will involved when you start, but not anymore once you're addicted. Actually addicted.
@fightingXstronger@xanga - it's difficult to stop, but they can. it isn't impossible. I don't doubt that it's tough and they want nothing more than to get high, but they don't have to. It's not your choice to think about it all the time, but it's your choice to actually do the drugs.
Unless you've known this life, you can't begin to understand it. No one starts doing drugs because they want to become a malnourished, homeless, smelly drug addict scouring the streets for money to buy their next fix. & yea, you hear all the hype. I don't know about anyone else but I always says I'd overdose & die before I got to that point.
It's just that it's always there, even when you've been clean forever. & sometimes you're like, "I just wanna feel that first high again. I'll stop after that."
But it's never that easy.
the addiction itself may not be a choice, but it's up to them whether they get help. i honestly believe that a lot of addicts are genuinely happy with their lives and don't want to change... which is sad and pathetic.
a close friend of mine was addicted to pain killers. when she realized it, she dropped EVERYTHING to get better. quit her job, dropped out of school, went into 24/7 rehab. that's what it takes to get better, and a lot of people just aren't willing to do that. i'm not sure why i should feel sorry for anyone who is an addict but doesn't WANT to seek help. your addiction doesn't affect your apathy. in fact, i'm pretty sure it was your apathy that got you into the situation where drugs were even an issue.
Both my Mother & I have what psychologists call "addictive personalities" .. & both of us have had our fair share of addictions. The only difference, is she is one of the people who believes its not her fault, its the addiction's fault. I refuse to believe that. YOU made the choices, not the drug. & I'm sorry, but anyone who says they "can't control it" is doing nothing but making excuses. Love this post & I really think you hit the nail on the head !
hahaha you just confirmed my suspicions...I really do live under a rock, I had no idea this show existed!!
I agree and I've been addicted cocaine - still smoke cigarettes too despite having tried to quit a billion times... I guess I just wanted to give you some credit here. I can see this post turning into a rather large argument... It's a really hard thing to say "addiction is a choice" because it is thought of like an incurable disease, and treated with a great degree of negativity from those that don't understand what it's like to be on drugs... "Choice" makes most think that the severity is less and the decisions will be easier. Yes, the addict had the choice to start using in the first place. Yes, making the choice NOT to use grows harder and harder the stronger the addiction becomes and the more rationale is blurred by the drug itself. YES... some people will never believe themselves worthy of anything more than the addiction itself because use has caused depression and a whole mess of problems they don't have to face when they're high... and thus they will never brave the prospect of getting clean unless forced to. But this is not always the case. I've had friends on both sides of the tracks - with addictions in the illegal substance area or in the form of eating disorders/compulsions. Some have had EVERY opportunity to get clean and in the end I have to say that they CHOSE death. Others, like myself, thought it was enough to hit bottom, seek out a trained professional, and get clean. (Staying clean isn't always this easy, and if you were to read my posts from the last 3-4yrs this would be evident. But I made the conscious decision to "see if I could handle it..." and quickly realized that my days of dabbling with uppers are over.) I took a Health Psychology class in my last year at university and the main focus was treating illness (physically and therapeutically) in as positive a manner as possible. The belief that one can overcome must remain greater than the prospect that they may fail in a battle against illness. 'Abstinence violation' is one of the most difficult obstacles an addict can face! But you see, you have to CHOOSE life - and that goes for anyone... addict or not.
Yeah, the drunk that killed my brother has never taken responsibility for her actions. She blames it all on alcohol and not on the fact that she made a CHOICE to go to the bar at 10:00 a.m. and sit there drinking Tequila all day and she made a CHOICE to get into her SUV and attempt to drive home when she was 4.5 times over the legal limit. It was the alcohol that slammed her SUV into the back of my brother's car causing his car to spin out and catch fire while he was trapped inside, still alive, and burned to death. It's an addiction, not a disease. I have a disease, Juvenile Diabetes, and I can't wake up one morning and decide not to take insulin and still live - you can wake up and decide not to take a drink and still live, or go ahead and take that drink and kill an innocent person.
@Ride_Every_Stride@xanga - Good point. It's an everyday battle. Making the decision to have a better life is easy (mostly) ...but staying in that mindset when you know what real escape feels like... well, that's another thing. I think that's the part that people don't understand - and it's the reason people relapse... =/
@flapper_femme_fatale@xanga - Wow. Judgey McJudgerson... Did you talk to your friend about WHY she was using pain killers? I don't think you have the right to call anyone sad and pathetic, especially if you've had someone so close to you who was obviously struggling to cope with life...
People who do drugs and get addicted aren't happy with themselves or their circumstances.
I agree with you. People with addictions make choices all the time. When you are an addict, it is easier to be an addict than it is to deal with real life. It is easier to give in to your addiction than it is to face the pain in your life. It is easier to say that I don't have a choice and I am not in control, than it is to realize that you are in control of your fate. Of course the temptation is always going to be there, but it is always up to the person with the addiction whether they are going to give in or not.
@dancingdoll86@xanga - my point was that my friend wasn't sad and pathetic, because she chose to get help and was willing to do whatever it took to get clean. being an addict isn't an excuse to refuse treatment. if addiction is a disease, then a lot of people seem to enjoy being diseased.
i'm not happy with my life, either. i haven't gotten addicted to anything because of it. so that's a terrible excuse for doing something that is not only (presumably) illegal, but dangerous. is recovery hard? absolutely. but, as the OP said, that's a choice you make. you can either get better, or continue on your path. if an addict chooses the latter, then they are no longer a victim of their addiction. they're making a conscious choice.
Things aren't as black and white as "choice" " no choice". (I also think in the end, everything has a biological reason, wether it's in your consciousness or not )
It often begins with a "normal" choice, but usually people just overestimate themselves. They don't think : "hey cool I''m gonna get all fucked look 10 years older in 2 years and lose custody over my children".
If you decide to recover you also have to make a choice. Many say they don't choose the addiction but they choose recovery. To an extend this is true. Like I said it's not so black and white.
I think if someone is so seriously messed up we cannot leave all responsibility about themselves to them as in "well it is YOUR fault if you die why would I bother". WE have to take care of them as a society...I think that's what we owe to each other s social beings in the family of humans.
The point is addicts do not feel like they have a choice in the same way that you feel you have a choice.
Also, they wouldn't do what they do without the drug. Assuming the individual can become healthy again, it would be unproportional to sentence them for something they did when they were an addict (basically a different person or "not themselves" as people say) because it's not like they'd do it again when they are healthy.
Interesting argument. I think at first anything is a choice, weather to take a hard drug, or kneeling before the porcelain god. However after a point there stops being a choice. and physiological addiction occurs. Thus people with an addiction after a point do not have a choice but to consume their choice of drug, or choice of behavior.
I agree 100% with you. Addiction IS a choice. Wether you want to continue to use or quit.
As a recovered Heroin and Meth addict I choose when to continue and when to stop. I knew I was going to with drawl and choose to continue on. Yes, I may have been addicted but my choices where made by ME on the drug but not the drug it's self. That's pure denial about addiction period. Yes, our thinking is different but when it comes down to it (a sober mind) I can tell you straight up that I made all the choices I made and no, they weren't the best ones but I take full responsibility for each and every one. As on Intervention, I was once saying the same thing as those people were about it being the drug but now being in recovery for a few years that was denial and afraid to admit I had a problem. At the time, I chose to keep being an addict rather than facing my own problems in life.
my best friend was a heavy drug iv drug user and addict for 6 years (I met him 2 yrs into it).. he nearly killed himself several times by OD, and almost every time I was the one who found him. The last time he said he was done, and went to rehab. He told me what it was like going through all the withdrawals and being so sick he couldn't move. Ive even read his journal, heck I helped write it some days because he couldn't hold the pen. He was most of the reason why I never wanted to experiment with drugs... I saw what they did to a person.
When I asked him why he started using, he didn't say it was because he was depressed or his life sucked. He said it was because his dad introduced him to it. He openly admits he made the choice, and he made the same choice every time he stuck the needle in his arm, or lit up. Until the last time someone offered to sell him some drugs, and he said no.
Yes, addiction is a choice.
Damn pretty much everyone has the same massive detailed outlook, At least there are others who feel this way. Might as well give my version. Excuse me in advance for my novel of a comment, but both addiction and my need to understand it, is a big part of my life. While not with the more heavy substances, I do struggle with addiction, with no denial of it. There are no excuses but I do feel that when it comes to addictions to the more severe substances, there are things to consider for both extremes. It's true that addicts are selfish, and often cause nothing but hurt to themselves and others, but robbing old ladies or selling their body probably wasn't plan A. And, of course depending on drug and usage, once your body adapts and/or becomes dependant, it's not a matter of just getting high anymore, but to avoid crippling withdrawals and by any means necessary. But it's worse when an addict or otherwise see it as being a helpless victim, it just seems to be a weak attempt to remove personal responsibility and all it does is hurt the chance of recovery by giving an excuse to use, relapse, or even to try get clean in the first place. Bottom line, addictions don't happen over night, they comes from repeated and increasingly bad choices until the addiction not only destroys them, but every one around them. And if even when addicts are able to get clean, recovery is a life long process, and weather they're actively using or not, will forever be addicts.
I think you've worded this incorrectly. You're questioning if using is the choice, not the addiction. Addiction, for some people, is not a choice. Some people can get hooked to things and some people can use and walk away any time.
Some drugs lower our inhibitions and cause us to do stupid, hurtful things because our perceptions are totally backwards. The psychosis that comes with withdrawals will cause people to do things they normally wouldn't. Your super-ego and your ego are dismissed because of the body's physical need to fulfill its addictions to whatever it's hooked to. The id takes the reigns and drives the individual into survival mode, doing what it can to feel right away and fulfill what its thinks is a basic need.
If you were starving, you may know its bad to steal someone's wallet to buy food, but you just might if you were that hungry. Same goes for addiction, only the mind is being weighed upon so much more heavily by drugs distorting your physical and mental system.
Is using a choice? To a degree. Does self-awareness negate responsibility or enforce it?
I don't think people who become addicted went into it expecting to be hooked, it WAS their choice to start drinking, or smoking, or shooting up, etc. And I agree that if they do something illegal that hurts others while under the influence, they should suffer the consequences of their actions. HOWEVER, I don't believe that being an addict is something you can control. If it was, THEN YOU WOULDN'T HAVE BECOME ADDICTED IN THE FIRST PLACE.
My boyfriend is a smoker, and he's been trying to quit for over three years. He still smokes, and he WILL keep smoking because right now, he can't help it. He can't stop. It's his stress reliever, it's the only thing that can calm him down if he gets too worked up, which happens pretty often. I wish he didn't, I have tried to help him, I have gotten ANGRY with him for ignoring my pleas. He sat me down, told me he loved me, but there was no way I could understand his addiction because I didn't know what it felt like to NEED something, to feel as if I'd die if I didn't smoke in the next five minutes. The stability of his world depends on his next cigarette, otherwise he couldn't function. He has improved a lot, and he's not allowed to smoke in the house or kiss me until he's brushed his teeth and washed off his face. It's a struggle, but I know he is trying to slowly detach himself from this burden.
That being said, if he ever murdered someone for the sake of a cigarette, I'd sell him down the river faster than it would take him to shower off his deed.
♥L
-SM
No drug is physically addictive. The brain will make the body think it needs a substance because the body is continually building a tolerance to the substance being abused.
Mind over matter.
Addiction to a substance is completely psychological. Fear of withdrawal is also completely psychological and it can be endured and overcome. It's all about mental strength and the will to overpower the addictive behavior. Drugs will most likely paralyze the already weak mind of an abuser.
They may need help/support quitting, but its their choice to take the first step and say "no more"
I think addiction is a choice, but nobody chose to be influenced by anybody to do something?
I thought the definition of an addiction is that if you are addicted, you cannot choose to stop on your own.
If you can just choose to stop, it was never a real addiction.
Starting is a choice...but addiction itself is not.
The author of this post has obviously never experienced addiction.